|
Up milling has
the thickest chip at the END of the cut.�
Thus, the thinnest chip is at the start of the cut.� At the very start of the cut, the cutter
will be trying to take too thin of a chip.�
(It�s like slicing anything- say for example deli meats.� In general any kind of a knife will
do.� But if you want real thin slices,
you need a super sharp cutter, like in the delis.� Even then there is a limit to how thin they
can slice your bologna, roast beef, etc.)�
So at the very start the up milling cutter does not cut, it deflects
SLIGHTLY and rubs along the surface.�
This builds up heat, and tends to wear the land on the relieved
portion of the tool.� By contrast Climb
milling starts the cutting where the chip is thickest and thus immediately
enters the workpiece.� There is no
rubbing thus the SURFACE FINISH is generally BETTER for CLIMB milling.� Further without the rubbing there is less
heat and wear, thus climb milling allows for faster feeds and speeds and
generally better tool life.� Finally,
in climb milling the cutter action acts to secure the part.� So why is up milling called conventional
.� If backlash is present climb milling
can� pull the workpiece into the tool
leading to an excessively deep cut- which can result in a fractured tool and
is a dangerous situation.� (If an up
milling cutter is sharper it cuts sooner/rubs less and gives better cut.� However its very rare for it to be sharp
enough to do better than a climbing cutter, though Kalpakjian seems to note
that it is possible.� In this class
climb milling=better cut.)� If you
don�t know how the machine will behave, it is safer (and as a general rule
better) to use up or conventional milling.�
If you are familiar with the machine, and know what sort backlash is
to be expected, you may want to use climb (down) milling-- provided you are
confident you can do it safely.� Most
NC machines generally have much tighter control of backlash (ball screws,
etc.) and can handle down milling.� On
hand operated machines, large backlashes can be present.� You should be careful about using down
milling in these cases.
|